Relationships

Once a Cheater, Always a Cheater? What Research Says

Is once a cheater always a cheater true? What research on serial infidelity shows, what raises and lowers the risk of repeat cheating, and signs of real change.

The Lovon Editorial Team
The Lovon Editorial TeamAuthor · Mental Health & Wellness Content Team
Published: Nov 14, 2026
7 min read

Key Takeaways

  • People who cheated in one relationship were about three times as likely to cheat in the next one, but more than half did not repeat.
  • Repeat risk is higher when the person sees cheating as acceptable, stays low on commitment, or never works out what led to it.
  • Real change shows up as months of consistent honesty and openness, not as intense apologies or promises in the first few weeks.

Once a cheater, always a cheater is not true for everyone, but it is not a myth either. In the main study on serial cheating, people who cheated in one relationship were about three times as likely to cheat in their next one: 45% did, compared with 18% of people who had not cheated before. That also means more than half did not repeat. A cheater can change, and whether one does depends on why it happened and what they do next.

Here is what the research shows, what raises and lowers the risk, and how to tell real change from promises.

What the research on serial cheating found

The key study followed 484 unmarried adults, aged 18 to 35 at the start, for about five years (Knopp et al., 2017). Participants filled out surveys every four to six months and reported on at least two different relationships. Each time, they were asked whether they had had sex with someone other than their partner, and whether their partner had.

Comparing the first relationship with the second, the researchers found:

Experience in the first relationshipSame experience in the next relationshipCompared with people who did not have it
Cheated themselves45% cheated again18%
Knew for sure a partner cheated22% knew the next partner cheated9%
Suspected a partner cheated37% suspected the next partner6%

The results held after accounting for age, gender, race, education, employment and income. They were the same for men and women, and for people who married during the study and people who did not.

The authors drew a careful conclusion. A history of cheating is an important risk factor, but most people who cheated in their first relationship did not report cheating again in the next one during the study. As they put it, it "is not necessarily true" that someone who is once a cheater is always a cheater.

A few limits are worth knowing:

  • Second relationships were shorter. They had lasted about 30 months on average by the end of the study, compared with about 39 for first relationships, and some were still going. Some repeat cheating may have come later.
  • Only sex was measured. Kissing, sexting and emotional affairs were not counted.
  • Agreements were unknown. Fewer than 2% said they were in an open relationship, but the study could not always tell whether outside sex was agreed.

Other research points the same way. In a study of 783 people in exclusive dating relationships, both men and women who had cheated in a prior relationship were more likely to cheat in their current one (Martins et al., 2016).

Why cheating once raises the odds

The researchers offer a few reasons past cheating carries forward:

  1. They know alternatives exist. Someone who has had an affair knows firsthand that other partners are available, and may keep believing they are.
  2. Attitudes shift. People with more accepting views of cheating are more likely to cheat. Having cheated also tends to make people's views more accepting, which eases the discomfort of having acted against their own values. Psychologists call that discomfort cognitive dissonance.
  3. Some traits travel with the person. Commitment depends on the relationship, but personality does not change when the partner does. People comfortable with sex outside commitment more often cheat for variety, and people with insecure attachment more often cheat out of anger, neglect or a need for esteem (Selterman et al., 2019).

What raises the risk of cheating again

These factors make cheating, including a repeat, more likely. The first five come from research. The last three are practical warning signs rather than research findings.

  • Accepting attitudes. "Everyone does it" or "it was just sex." More positive attitudes toward infidelity were linked to cheating for both men and women (Martins et al., 2016).
  • Low commitment. Keeping one foot out of the relationship.
  • A sense that better options are everywhere. Researchers call this the perceived quality of alternatives, and it also predicted cheating in the same study.
  • An unhappy relationship that stays unhappy. Low relationship satisfaction is one of the strongest predictors of cheating (Vowels et al., 2022).
  • Cheating for variety. This motive is tied to a person's general attitude toward sex, not to a passing situation (Selterman et al., 2019).
  • No real understanding of why it happened. "I don't know, it just happened" leaves the conditions in place.
  • Ongoing contact with the affair partner, including "just friends."
  • Blaming the partner. If the cheating was your fault, they do not have to change anything.

What lowers the risk

  • Working out what led to it. The study's authors suggest that helping people identify the circumstances behind past cheating is a way to keep it from carrying into future relationships. They also note that a couple's ability to talk through what led up to an affair is seen as a strong sign of recovery.
  • Changing the situation, not just making a promise. If the motive was situational, like drinking on work trips or a coworker who became a confidant, the situation has to change. Situational affairs also tend to be shorter and less tied to the relationship than affairs driven by anger or lost love (Selterman et al., 2021).
  • Fixing what was wrong between you. Since relationship satisfaction is such a strong predictor, the researchers behind that work suggest that keeping the relationship healthy may do more to prevent cheating than focusing on personality (PsyPost, 2021).
  • Coming clean. In a small study of 19 couples dealing with an affair, part of a larger couple therapy trial, those whose affair was revealed before or during treatment improved more in relationship satisfaction than couples with no affair, even though they started out more distressed (Atkins et al., 2005).
  • Structured help. In a treatment designed for couples recovering from an affair, most of the six couples studied were less distressed by the end, and the hurt partners reported more forgiveness (Gordon, Baucom & Snyder, 2004). These studies are small, but they show recovery is possible.

Can a cheater change?

Yes, and many do. The data say a past affair raises the odds, not that it seals the outcome. What separates people who change from people who repeat is less about how sorry they feel and more about what they do over time.

Change usually looks unexciting. It is ordinary honesty, repeated. It is answering the same hard question for the fifth time without sighing. It is offering information before being asked. Big gestures and tearful promises in the first weeks can be sincere, but they are easy to make, so on their own they tell you little.

Signs of real change vs. promises

Real changeJust promises
Ends all contact with the affair partner, and you can see itSays it is over but stays "friends"
Tells you the full truth, including what you did not already knowAdmits only what you can already prove
Explains what led to it without blaming you"You pushed me away" or "you made it easy"
Stays patient with your questions over monthsGets annoyed that you are "still on this"
Offers openness about phone, plans and timeTreats every question as an attack on privacy
Changes habits: drinking, travel, certain friendshipsBig gestures and gifts, little else
Gets help, alone or as a couple, and keeps goingAgrees to counseling, then cancels
Is just as consistent at month six as in week oneIntense remorse that fades fast

A useful test: are they working on why it happened, or only on getting you to stop being upset?

If you were cheated on in a past relationship

The same study found two patterns on the other side. People who knew a previous partner had cheated were more likely to say the same of their next partner, 22% versus 9%. The authors could not say why. And people who suspected a previous partner were much more likely to suspect the next one too, 37% versus 6%. That second finding suggests suspicion can travel between relationships, whatever the new partner is doing.

If you notice old alarms going off with someone new, it helps to ask whether something is happening now or whether it reminds you of then. The trust issues test can show where that wariness comes from.

If you are the one who cheated

If you want to make sure it does not happen again, the work is concrete:

  1. Name the motive. Anger, neglect, variety, a boost to your ego, a situation you walked into. Why people cheat lays out the eight common motives.
  2. Name the conditions. Who, where, when, and what made it easy.
  3. Change the conditions. End the contact, change the routine, say the hard thing to your partner that you were avoiding.
  4. Watch your own story. If you catch yourself thinking "it wasn't that bad" or "anyone would have," that is the attitude shift the research warns about.

The guilt can be heavy. How to forgive yourself for cheating helps you deal with it without brushing past what happened.

Deciding whether to give a second chance

There is no score that tells you whether to stay. What you can look at is evidence: what happened since you found out, and whether it matches the "real change" column above. The Should I Forgive Cheating? quiz walks through the signs that rebuilding is realistic.

If you decide to try, how to rebuild trust after cheating gives a step-by-step plan, and how long it takes to rebuild trust sets realistic expectations. For the bigger picture on how often people cheat and repeat, see cheating statistics.

If you want to think it through out loud, Lovon is an AI relationship coach you can talk to any time.

How AI Support Helps You Heal

AI emotional support isn't about replacing human connection — it's about filling the gaps. The moments when you need to talk at 2 AM, when you don't want to burden your friends again, or when you simply need someone to listen without judgment.

Here's what happens in a typical Lovon session:

1

You share what's on your mind

There's no script, no intake form, no waiting room. You speak or type whatever you're feeling — in your own words, at your own pace.

2

Lovon validates and explores

Using frameworks from CBT (Cognitive Behavioral Therapy) and motivational interviewing, Lovon acknowledges your feelings first, then gently helps you explore them. No dismissive "just move on" advice.

3

You build coping skills together

Lovon doesn't just listen — it actively works with you on evidence-based techniques: thought reframing, urge surfing, behavioral experiments, and more.

What a Session with Lovon Looks Like

A Lovon voice session — talking out loud to an AI companion

Lovon is AI support, not a replacement for professional care. If things have been hard to get through for weeks, or you are thinking about harming yourself, talk to a doctor or a licensed therapist.

Ready to Start?

Your healing journey can begin right now

A 3-day trial. No judgment. Just a safe space to process what you're going through.

Start a ConversationTakes 30 seconds
Summarize this article with AI:

Frequently Asked Questions

Is once a cheater always a cheater true?
Not as a rule. In the main study on serial cheating, 45% of people who cheated in one relationship cheated in their next, compared with 18% of those who had not. That is a real increase in risk, but more than half did not repeat.
Can a cheater change?
Yes, but it takes more than remorse. Change is most believable when the person understands what led to the cheating, ends contact with the affair partner, tells the truth without being pushed, and stays consistent over months.
Will someone who cheated cheat again in the same relationship?
Research mostly tracks cheating across different relationships, so there is less data on repeat cheating with the same partner. What matters most is whether the affair has fully ended and whether the conditions that made it possible have changed.
Are people who cheated more likely to suspect their next partner?
Not according to research. One study found no link between cheating yourself and suspecting a later partner. People who had suspected a previous partner were, however, much more likely to suspect the next one.
What are signs that a cheater has really changed?
They cut off the affair partner completely, answer questions honestly instead of only admitting what you can prove, explain what led to it without blaming you, and stay patient with your bad days. Most important, they keep doing this for months, not weeks.
If I was cheated on before, will it happen again?
Your risk is somewhat higher, but far from certain. In one study, 22% of people who knew a previous partner had cheated said the same of their next partner, compared with 9% of others. Most did not have it happen again during the study.

About the Author

The Lovon Editorial Team

The Lovon Editorial Team

Mental Health & Wellness Content Team

The Lovon Editorial Team develops mental health and wellness content designed to make psychological concepts accessible and actionable. Our goal is to bridge the gap between clinical research and everyday life - helping you understand why your mind works the way it does and what you can do about it....

Quizzes

Free tools

From the wiki

  • What is considered cheating?

    There is no universal list, which is why the answer depends on the agreement the two of you actually have, usually one…

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition. If you are in crisis or think you may have an emergency, call 988 (Suicide & Crisis Lifeline) or go to the nearest emergency room. Outside the US? Find a crisis line in your country.